Extending your online course - (2nd Nov - 4th Dec 2011)
Wk 1. Attitudes to identity, privacy & disclosure:
I've just completed this very useful and interesting online course run by
Oxford Brookes.
We looked at some of the social media tools that are available for teaching & learning online, and discussed the pros and cons of each. I was also introduced to tools that I hadn't previously seen or used, such as social citation tools including
Zotero and
Bibsonomy, which enable sharing of bibliographies, online reference management & bookmarking etc.
Initially I found it quite difficult engaging fully with the course, as it felt strange posting comments and responses on the discussion forum, to be read by people that I've never met or been properly introduced to - but then this is how it works for a distance learning course, and it's useful experience for me to see it from a student's perspective.
I also felt that although there was regular tutor feedback/delivery at least once a week, it was quite isolating and completing the tasks required a great deal of self motivation. In terms of time spent, I needed between 6-8 hrs each week to feel I was properly engaging with the tasks and to read through the selected articles/links etc.
The course was very much student-led, rather than tutor led, with us, as the students, dictating how much we engaged and often dictating our own learning.
My notes from the course:
Useful Reading:
White, D. (2011). The Learning Black Market.
Tall blog. Online Education with the University of Oxford. Retrieved 5 December 2011 from
http://tallblog.conted.ox.ac.uk/index.php/2011/09/30/the-learning-black-market/
Students aren't entirely confident at using a list of resources from a google search - they want to go to a structured list located on a VLE, provided by an academic. This way, they know it has been critically evaluated and recommended - they are confident of its accuracy.
Teaching staff want to know that the resources are quality controlled, so they prefer to go to 'known' 'reputable' places such as BBC or other universities etc.
Advice:
- provide a digital reading list on your VLE for the students (should include multimedia too, such as video clips etc)
- students need advice on how to incorporate digital media in their work, i.e podcasts, videos etc. They need advice on how to correctly cite things - need guidelines / digital literacy etc.
Useful Reading:
Prensky, M. (2001). Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants.
On the Horizon (MCB University Press) 9(5), 1-6. Retrieved 6 December 2011 from
http://www.marcprensky.com/writing/
White, D. & Le Cornu, A. (2011). Visitors and residents: a new typology for online engagement. First Monday, 16(9). Retrieved 6 December 2011, from
http://firstmonday.org/htbin/cgiwrap/bin/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/3171/3049
David White et al challenge Prensky's Digital Native & Digital Immigrants theory, seeing 2 different categories of online users - Visitors & Residents. This argues Prensky's view that web/online/digital skills are dependant on age and the decade in which one is born. It argues that it is more to do with how we perceive the web and social media, and how far we choose to engage with it.
Residents: those regularly using social media etc. Posting on Twitter etc. Tend to leave a 'presence' online.
Visitors: tap in as & when they need to - tend not to have anything permanent online.
The Visitor sees the web as a collection of tools. NB: they're no less technologically adept, but they only want it for what they need from it educationally. They see it as a 'toolbox' and 'rummage' around for the tool they need, & then put it back again when they have finished with it.
The Resident sees the web as a social space (like a park on a nice sunny afternoon!) - somewhere to meet others and have a chat, and to engage with the outside world.
All participants on the course were asked to complete Katie Piatt’s quiz: "Are you a Digital Resident or a Digital Visitor?" at
http://katiepiatt.blogspot.com/2011/10/are-you-digital-resident-or-digital.html
Not surprisingly I came out as a visitor! I know that I see the web as a 'tool' and do not feel at all comfortable having a presence online. I do not use Facebook or Twitter and am wary of posting any personal details online.
I don't really 'get' Facebook! Of course I see its benefits in terms of the opportunities it provides for collaboration amongst peers etc, but the whole idea of living out one's life online and visible to all, or at least, to many, really makes me uneasy. I see Facebook's role being one that brings out the voyeurist in people, allowing them to view areas of other people's lives that might otherwise remain hidden (unless you are a close friend or relative), such as their family members, their houses, their partners, their past lives........etc. You can even find out what they are doing right now and read messages from other friends. Of course, many users choose to set their privacy settings so that only close friends and family can view such information, but many, surprisingly, leave it open to all!! This reveals an exhibitionist side in people that I also find hard to relate to!
The following article discusses how social media can be manipulated to suit our privacy needs, and that most (particularly young) people understand how to 'play the game', i.e we like to watch and be watched, but have the knowledge/skill/means of maintaining control of our own privacy when we choose, without having to entirely opt out of social networks:
Boyd, Danah. (2011). Dear Voyeur, meet Flaneur... Sincerely, Social Media. Surveillance and society, 8(4), 505-507. Retrieved February 10, 2011, from
http://www.surveillance-and-society.org/ojs/index.php/journal/article/view/privacy_response3/privacy_response3